Looking for the best pizza in Oviedo, FL?
Oviedo has become a surprisingly good place for pizza lovers. Around town, you’ll find everything from classic New York-style pizza and traditional Italian restaurants to brick-oven pies and more modern artisan creations.
Whether you’re searching for pizza near Oviedo, planning a family dinner, grabbing a casual slice, or looking for somewhere new to try, there are several local pizza restaurants worth knowing about.
And we’re including one restaurant that’s a little outside Oviedo — Flippers Pizza Co. in Lake Mary — because sometimes a great pizza is worth going slightly off the path.

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Oviedo
Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza – Oviedo
Located at 10 Alexandria Boulevard, Mister O1 brings a more contemporary artisan approach to pizza in Oviedo.
The restaurant is especially well known for its thin-crust pizzas and signature star-shaped pies, which feature ricotta-filled pockets around the crust.
The menu offers plenty of combinations that go beyond standard pepperoni and cheese, making Mister O1 a strong option when you’re looking for something a little more creative.
Best for: Artisan pizza, specialty pies, date nights and trying something different.
Cucinella’s Brick Oven Pizzeria
Cucinella’s Brick Oven Pizzeria
For anyone specifically searching for brick-oven pizza in Oviedo, Cucinella’s Brick Oven Pizzeria is a neighborhood spot worth checking out.
Located at 254 N Division Street near Downtown Oviedo, Cucinella’s focuses on traditional pizza prepared in a brick oven.
Its location also makes it particularly convenient for Downtown Oviedo as well as residents coming from Geneva, Chuluota and the eastern side of town.
Best for: Brick-oven pizza, casual dinners and a locally rooted Oviedo pizzeria.
Café Panuzzo’s
Café Panuzzo’s has been part of the Oviedo dining scene for years and offers considerably more than just pizza.
Located at 1003 Lockwood Boulevard, Panuzzo’s combines pizza with a larger Italian-inspired menu, making it a good choice when you’re dining with a group where everyone may want something different.
You can come for pizza while someone else at the table chooses pasta, Italian entrées or one of the restaurant’s other specialties.
Best for: Family dinners, Italian food, pizza and groups looking for a larger menu.
Backstreet Pizza & Pub
Backstreet Pizza & Pub is a great option when you’re looking for a classic neighborhood pizza experience.
Located at 1949 County Road 419, Backstreet describes itself as a scratch kitchen serving New York-style pizza, wings, subs, pasta and Italian dishes. The restaurant serves Oviedo, Chuluota, Geneva and the surrounding communities.
Its location makes it especially convenient for residents around Live Oak Reserve, Riverside, Chuluota and eastern Oviedo.
Best for: New York-style pizza, casual pizza nights, families and groups.
Giovanni’s Pizzeria & Kitchen
Located at 4250 Alafaya Trail, Giovanni’s Pizzeria & Kitchen is another established pizza and Italian food option on the UCF side of Oviedo.
Its location makes Giovanni’s convenient for neighborhoods around Alafaya Trail, UCF, University Boulevard, Carillon and southern Oviedo.
Because the menu extends beyond pizza, it also works well for families and larger groups where everyone isn’t necessarily looking for the same type of meal.
Best for: Pizza, Italian entrées, families and the UCF/Oviedo area.
Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary
Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary
Here’s the one that’s slightly off the traditional Oviedo pizza path.
Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary is located at 120 N 4th Street in Downtown Lake Mary. While it isn’t technically an Oviedo restaurant, it’s close enough to be worth considering when you’re willing to venture a little farther for a different style of pizza.
And Flippers isn’t trying to be another standard pizza chain.

Flippers Pizza Co Near Oviedo FL
All-Natural Craft Pizza
Flippers specializes in all-natural craft pizza made with carefully selected ingredients and brick-oven cooking.
Its pizza dough is cold fermented for 96+ hours, while sauces and dressings are made in-house and vegetables are roasted in-house.
The menu includes traditional favorites alongside more adventurous combinations.
Pepperoni Napoli
The Pepperoni Napoli combines crushed DOP San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, pepperoni, fresh oregano and extra virgin olive oil.
Honey Badger
For something with a little more personality, the Honey Badger combines crushed DOP San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, Italian sausage, salami, red pepper flakes, red onions, Peppadew peppers, fresh basil and local raw hot honey.
Margherita
The classic Margherita keeps things simple with crushed DOP San Marzano tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil and extra virgin olive oil.
Build Your Own Pizza
Flippers also offers Build Your Own pizzas, making it easy to customize a pie around different preferences.
That can be particularly helpful for families and groups where everyone has their own idea of what belongs on a pizza.
More Than Pizza
Flippers Lake Mary also offers fresh salads, oven-baked wings, handhelds, shareables and sweets alongside its pizza menu. Vegetarian, vegan and gluten-friendly choices are also available.
For dine-in guests, Flippers offers its Artisan Pairing, which pairs a 9-inch pizza with a half Italian or Caesar salad for $11.99. The Lake Mary location also currently offers weekday happy hour Monday through Friday from 3 PM to 6 PM.
So while Lake Mary might fall just outside your original search for the best pizza in Oviedo, Flippers gives Seminole County pizza lovers another option when they want craft pizza, premium ingredients and something a little different from the neighborhood pizza shop.
What Kind of Pizza Are You Looking For?
There really isn’t just one style of pizza around Oviedo.
If you’re looking for creative artisan pizza right in town, Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza brings a distinctive approach with its specialty and star-shaped pizzas.
For a traditional neighborhood brick-oven experience, Cucinella’s Brick Oven Pizzeria is conveniently located near Downtown Oviedo.
If you’re looking for pizza alongside a broader Italian menu, Café Panuzzo’s and Giovanni’s Pizzeria & Kitchen give you plenty of additional choices.
For New York-style pizza and a laid-back neighborhood atmosphere, Backstreet Pizza & Pub serves Oviedo, Chuluota and Geneva.
And when you’re willing to go slightly outside Oviedo, Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary brings all-natural craft pizza, brick-oven cooking and a menu built around premium ingredients.
Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza in Oviedo
What are some of the best pizza places in Oviedo, FL?
Oviedo has several popular pizza options representing different styles. Local choices include Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza, Cucinella’s Brick Oven Pizzeria, Café Panuzzo’s, Backstreet Pizza & Pub and Giovanni’s Pizzeria & Kitchen.
Pizza lovers willing to expand their search into nearby Seminole County can also visit Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary for all-natural craft pizza.
Where can I find brick-oven pizza near Oviedo?
Cucinella’s Brick Oven Pizzeria is located directly in Oviedo.
A little farther away, Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary serves all-natural craft pizza along with salads, wings, handhelds and other menu options.
Is there New York-style pizza in Oviedo?
Yes. Backstreet Pizza & Pub specifically features New York-style pizza along with wings, subs, pasta and Italian dishes.
Are there vegan or gluten-friendly pizza options near Oviedo?
Options vary by restaurant, but Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary offers vegan cheese as well as a gluten-friendly pizza crust.
Guests with allergies or celiac disease should always speak directly with the restaurant about preparation procedures and potential cross-contact before ordering.
Is Flippers Pizza Co. near Oviedo?
Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary is located in Downtown Lake Mary at 120 N 4th St., Lake Mary, FL 32746. The restaurant offers dine-in, carry-out and delivery and is currently open daily from 10 AM to midnight.
It isn’t technically in Oviedo, which is why we consider it our “worth the short drive” addition to this list.
Finding Your Favorite Pizza Around Oviedo
One of the best things about searching for pizza around Oviedo is the variety.
You can stay in town for artisan pizza, New York-style pizza, brick-oven pies and Italian neighborhood restaurants — or broaden the search into the surrounding Seminole County communities.
So the next time you’re searching for best pizza in Oviedo, pizza near Oviedo, brick-oven pizza in Oviedo or pizza restaurants near me, don’t be afraid to expand the map a little.
Sometimes one of the most interesting options is just outside the usual search radius.
For pizza lovers looking for an excuse to take a short trip up the road, Flippers Pizza Co. – Lake Mary is one worth putting on the list.

